Presented by Ricardo & Wasylik, PL

A Florida pension fund for firefighters and police has sued Nationstar Mortgage for securities fraud, alleging that Nationstar executives concealed a variety of unsavory dealings from its potential investors. The complaint alleges:

[U]nbeknownst to investors… defendants knew or recklessly disregarded that:

(a) Nationstar’s deficiencies in management control and supervision rendered it unable to comply with laws and regulations applicable to servicing MSRs [mortgage servicing rights];

(b) Nationstar was gouging mortgagors – and illegally enhancing its profits through unsustainable means – via illicit practices, such as charging for repeated, unnecessary inspections, which resulted in additional late payment fees, and by pressuring mortgagors to carry out expensive modifications and refinancing of their mortgages;

(c) Solutionstar’s increasing profitability was largely attributable to unlawful and inappropriate customer gouging, rather than improving business metrics;

(d) Heightened regulatory scrutiny into MSR transferring and servicing – including a probe into Nationstar’s own loan servicing practices launched by the New York State Department of Financial Services (“NY DFS”) in March 2014 – had significantly increased Nationstar’s costs of servicing MSRs and diminished the profitability and carrying value of the Company’s MSR portfolio;

(e) In order to deflect regulatory scrutiny in the wake of the regulatory enforcement actions taken against Ocwen, Nationstar had abandoned certain of its own abusive loan servicing practices and adopted others required by regulators, which had made its loan servicing business less profitable and rendered Nationstar’s MSR portfolio less valuable to the Company…

…In January 2015, Nationstar was named as a defendant in a federal civil action accusing the Company of racketeering activity and seeking hundreds of millions of dollars in damages on a classwide basis and alleging that the Company essentially paid itself kickbacks through its Solutionstar billings for improper fees.

…While Nationstar blamed the decline [in profits] on lower interest rates causing higher pre- payments, commentators recognized that in reality, it was “heightened scrutiny into the servicing space by regulators such as the Benjamin Lawsky-headed New York Department of Financial Services” which had significantly diminished profits in and the carrying value of the Company’s servicing business.

(Italics mine.)

In other words, Nationstar juiced its profit reporting through illegal, unfair, or just plain bad business practices, and when it was forced to abandon those illegal practices to avoid government investigations of its practices, its profitability fell, and its investors suffered.

The case is CITY OF ST. CLAIR SHORES POLICE AND FIRE RETIREMENT SYSTEM v. NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE HOLDINGS INC. and you can read the complaint here: Nationstar Complaint [PDF]


Want to know more? Contact us at Ricardo & Wasylik, PL.

U.S. v. Bartram: Appellate court guts five-year limitations law (briefs available)

May 1, 2014

Imagine a bank that can lose a foreclosure suit, file it again, lose it again, file it again, and so on—with virtually no limits whatsoever as to the number of times they can file or the time they have to accomplish it. In a surprising ruling, the Fifth District Court of Appeal effectively stripped away […]

Read the full article →

How to Fabricate Evidence: Wells Fargo’s Foreclosure Manual Confirms the Worst

March 15, 2014
Thumbnail image for How to Fabricate Evidence: Wells Fargo’s Foreclosure Manual Confirms the Worst

If there was any doubt in your mind that banks have been forging evidence, put it to rest. According to the New York Post, an internal Wells Fargo manual has now leaked confirming the exact procedures Wells and its attorneys use to fabricate evidence in foreclosure cases—down to the computer codes they use to order […]

Read the full article →

David Stern Disbarred, Recommends Florida Bar Referee

October 28, 2013
Thumbnail image for David Stern Disbarred, Recommends Florida Bar Referee

The case of Florida Bar v. David J. Stern just reached its next-to-last step, as the judge presiding over the hearing recommended disbarment. The report is scathing. Read it for yourself: Florida Bar v. David J. Stern: Report of Referee [PDF]

Read the full article →

Can You Cancel Your Mortgage Based on Forged Signatures?

October 9, 2013
Thumbnail image for Can You Cancel Your Mortgage Based on Forged Signatures?

You’ve got a forged signature in your mortgage documents. You’ve got them dead to rights—there’s no doubt it’s a fake. You’re excited, because you think you might have a free house. So, can you cancel your mortgage? The answer may surprise you. Who Else Wants a Free House? A lot of homeowners call us, having […]

Read the full article →

The Florida Bar v. David J Stern: No Harm, No Foul?

October 1, 2013
Thumbnail image for The Florida Bar v. David J Stern: No Harm, No Foul?

Although many people have heard of the Florida foreclosure kingpin David J. Stern, not many of those people get to see him in person.  And I, who have litigated hundreds of cases against his law firm, never saw the man before today, when I testified in the trial of the numerous bar complaints against Stern. […]

Read the full article →

The Mandate from Tallahassee: Ease Up on Banks or Crack the Whip?

September 27, 2013
Thumbnail image for The Mandate from Tallahassee: Ease Up on Banks or Crack the Whip?

The Angry Judge and the Mandate from Tallahassee We had settled the case, and the judge was furious. She stood up from her seat, looming over us from the bench, and yelled at the at me and the bank’s lawyer. We had dared to agree to postpone the foreclosure sale date so the bank would […]

Read the full article →

Is Smith, Hiatt, and Diaz (SHD Legal) about to go under?

June 6, 2013
Thumbnail image for Is Smith, Hiatt, and Diaz (SHD Legal) about to go under?

The law firm of Smith, Hiatt and Diaz has been in trouble before, but since January of this year there have been several warning signs that the firm may be in fatal trouble. I thought it was strange when, in January, the firm failed to show up for two hearings in a single week—one of […]

Read the full article →

The biggest mistake you can make in fighting your foreclosure: hiring the WRONG lawyer

May 17, 2013

Don’t hire the WRONG foreclosure defense lawyers Sometimes having the wrong lawyer is worse than having no lawyer at all. Here’s a redacted paragraph out of a recent decision by Florida Fifth District Court of Appeal about the shoddy work of one defense law firm: The quality of the legal work performed by [defense] attorneys […]

Read the full article →

David J. Stern: Florida Bar files 17-count complaint

April 18, 2013

Almost everyone knows that the Law Office of Davis J. Stern has been out of operation for more than two years now,even though the legal entity still exists (mainly for the purpose of suing its former clients for fees). But Stern himself looks like he’s about to lose his license. On April 17, the Florida […]

Read the full article →

Big Four Banks Apologize for Wreaking Economic Havoc and Promise to “Make it right.”

April 1, 2013
Thumbnail image for Big Four Banks Apologize for Wreaking Economic Havoc and Promise to “Make it right.”

NEW YORK, April 1—The leaders of the nation’s largest banks held a press conference today to apologize to the nation for the disastrous impact their greed and short-sightedness has had on the U.S. economy since the turn of the century. Bank of America, Wells Fargo, Citibank, and JP Morgan Chase all vowed that they would […]

Read the full article →

Only 15% of national mortgage fraud settlement benefits Florida homeowners

February 23, 2013

Remember when the feds and the Attorneys General of the various states announced the settlement of claims arising from the robo-signing scandal? Remember how they promised that $26 billion dollars would go to help victim of foreclosure fraud? Will you be surprised to learn it didn’t exactly happen that way? Me neither. A new report […]

Read the full article →

Pinellas Residents:
Contact Florida Senator Jack Latvala to OPPOSE foreclosure fast-track legislation

February 11, 2013
Thumbnail image for Pinellas Residents:  <br>Contact Florida Senator Jack Latvala to OPPOSE foreclosure fast-track legislation

No Senator has yet introduced a companion bill to HB 87—but rumor has it Sen. Jack Latvala will be instrumental in one when it gets drafted. Here’s the Senator’s information: Tallahassee Office: 408 Senate Office Building 404 South Monroe Street Tallahassee, FL 32399-1100 (850) 487-5020 Please contact Set. Latvala today Our sources tell us […]

Read the full article →

Florida’s foreclosure fast-track bill may expose state to billions of dollars in liability under Bert Harris Act

February 11, 2013

The Florida legislature is once again considering a bill to fast-track foreclosure cases in the judicial system—even though no one wants to use the expedited procedure that already exists—and one of the most dangerous provisions the bill contains is the so-called “Finality of judgment” section. The finality provision This finality provision is backed by well-funded […]

Read the full article →

An open letter to Florida’s lawmakers

February 6, 2013

Dear Subcommittee Members, Party Leaders, and all Legislators: Vote NO on House Bill 87. If you’ve never stepped foot in a foreclosure courtroom, vote NO HB 87, because you cannot understand what the real problem is. If you think that the speed of foreclosure is the fault of Florida’s homestead property owners, then vote NO […]

Read the full article →

The “Bring a court action” language does not substantially comply with Paragraph 22, says Broward County judge in blistering opinion

January 24, 2013

What’s the biggest battle raging on the front lines of the foreclosure wars? The failure of nearly all the banks to comply with the pre-acceleration notice requirements contained in paragraph 22 of the mortgage. The bank’s breach vs. substantial compliance On the defense side, we see that nearly every letter that goes out contains some […]

Read the full article →

Another one bites the dust: Spear and Hoffman, minor foreclosure mill, to close its doors

January 8, 2013

A day after we learned aout the impending closure of Marshall C Watson, P.A., we have now learned that Spear and Hoffman P.A., a relatively small foreclosure mill based in Miami, is also shutting its doors soon. This one seems to be financial, rather than any wrongdoing—the firm had a much smaller volume than most […]

Read the full article →

Marshall Watson to surrender law license and close law firm

January 8, 2013

Marshall C. Watson, the lawyer at the head of one of Florida’s most notorious foreclosure mills, will soon surrender his law license and shut down his infamous law firm, reports the Palm Beach Post’s Kim Miller. According to the Post: The owner of the Fort Lauderdale-based Law Offices of Marshall C. Watson has agreed to […]

Read the full article →

One little letter to save your home: Florida appellate court rejects “substantial compliance” in Judy

December 1, 2012
Thumbnail image for One little letter to save your home: Florida appellate court rejects “substantial compliance” in <em>Judy</em>

One little letter stands between you and the bank that wants to take your home, if you’re in foreclosure. Those of you following recent developments in foreclosure law know that a defense, first developed by the foreclosure lawyers at Ricardo & Wasylik, has been taking the state by storm: the defective notice letters sent by […]

Read the full article →